Showing posts with label Watashi no Okusuri. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Watashi no Okusuri. Show all posts

21 March 2016

IMHO. 'Shiori ojousama wa shiitagerareru' by Takamiya Satoru ~ Shiori young lady It is oppressed

That's what the cover says. Engrish, you know? And the story went just as the title was: completely wrong, but probably they did not aim for anything better anyway.

story and characters
The funniest thing is that Sakae, our Hero, is completely right - if a guy teases the heroine constantly, and then suddenly becomes all tender and caring, this gap is what's so precious and wonderful.
By the way, this gap is not limited to only one kind of story. It can be a cold-blooded knight who seems not to care about love or romance, but then finds his fair lady and swears to protect her. It can be a playboy who looks like he doesn't want any serious relationship, but then finds his only one. It can be a proud lone wolf who initially hates the Heroine, but after knowing her better, gradually grows to like her. It can be a perfect guy who shouldn't be interested in a girl like the protagonist - because he can easily find a 'better' one, but actually wants exactly her. Or a positive boy who looks carefree, but turns out to be too shy to express his real feelings when the time comes. And I, being a very narrow-minded person, always believed that this sudden change in the Hero's attitude was the best thing in shoujo.
There is that wonderful word in Japanese I like very much: 'yoyuu', which means 'having enough' of sth, like time or money or possibilities. It's also used to describe a person who looks like he's not bothered at all by the problems that lie in front of him and dealing with them is a piece of cake for him. I thought we, female readers, want to see the Hero lose his 'yoyuu', or  'freedom', when he falls in love with the girl in focus.
But what we have here in 'Shiori ojousama' is actually a girl who, after some inner struggle, admits that she loves being teased, to such an extent that she eventually finds herself unable to judge the feelings of her partner other than by his teasing. Sometimes she reaches her limit and snaps at him, but it's enough for him to say he was doing it for her sake, and she's again satisfied. So when he finally starts treating her gently, she deliberately refuses.
Basically, it's not a problem that he teases her. And it's not a problem that she likes it either. After all, who would read a manga where the characters simply get along very well from the beginning to the end with no development, misunderstandings or obstacles. The problem is, Sakae never had to put up with anything, and his occasional confessions were absolutely unrealistic and uninspiring (Stanislavsky would say 'I don't believe you!'). In other words, I wouldn't want to have such a guy by my side, and I cannot imagine a girl who would, either.

Graphics
This is obviously not a manga for admiring, it's a manga for reading. This itself is no disadvantage, I know many a manga where art was nothing special, but the story made up for that. However, 'Shiori' looks like it's made by a graduated-from-being-an-amateur-month-ago.

Conclusion
After reading another short story by Ms Takamiya - 'watashi no okusuri', I thought I was about to discover a new solid source of shoujo manga. However after 'Shiori', I guess I will be reading this author no more.

22 April 2011

my humble opinion on mangas I read ~ part number what?

"Kuroneko Guardian" by Izumi Asuka
that`s the kind of guys who seem to be girlish and the kind of girls who are tomboys, speaking simply. as for me I get it - we have an ethic-intuine boy and logic-sensoric girl... that`s nothing wrong to me. that`s why I like it
"Moujuu wa Ori no Naka" by Toyota Yuu
that`s just the greatest success! ehm... I mean, it was the thing I liked most. no, I loved this! though the theme was not very unique, I liked the plot even (the pics are not very mature as well... but who cares when we have such relations!!! a girl and her beast *___*)
I`d love to read something else with the same concept...
"Nageku Shinigami" by Mitsubachi Miyuki
I almost cried in the end being so touched by this... but then I thought... it`s really not right! exchanging memories for a new life... it`s not how things should go. I don`t quite love such stories trying to be sad and make you sorry for the characters when there are lots of thing yet to be explained
"Rakuen" by Fujiwara Kaoru
I was waiting for some sad and sophisticated story... I was mistaken
the first chapter was all right though I didn't like it very much. but I understood what the style is and it was o`k
the second was very short and I didn't understand what`s the meaning of that. just some beautiful pics? oh that`s not what I came for
the 3rd was toooo sophisticated. can I call it this way? it was depressive. and moreover it was dull. there`s nothing really beautiful in the things described. and the meaning is not impressive either. I start thinking she is somewhat crazy
the last one proved I was right. a girl gets fond of being f*cked both by a guy and by herself and her hand turns into a wolf. what`s the matter??? is it supposed to have some philosophy? or some moral? or just any thoughts or ideas? there are none. I hate this pathetic attempt to look like a cool author for some elite readership
I`m not gonna read her other mangas though I intended to
"Watashi no Okusuri" 
this was just one of the greatest things I've read recently. the length and the plot and the characters are suitable to each other and even the graphics doesn't spoil the impression. I've reread the favourite moments like... 5 times? or something like that
"Watashi no Suki na Hito" by CLAMP
it`s a bunch of one-shots each one dedicated to some word, better to say - concept... and each one is nice and simply great. it's shoujo and it`s not super-original but I was glad to read every single chapter. so I think this is the thing which distinguishes a good author from the bad
"Yami no Kakan" by Higuri Yuu
I was afraid of reading the main manga but I read this short story without knowing its relation to the main one and I liked the prequel so much that I'm going to read the main now ^_